Am I affected?

type your cloak version to check

Description

Use of Password Hash With Insufficient Computational Effort vulnerability in danielberkompas cloak_ecto and danielberkompas cloak allows an attacker who holds the hashed values and the configured secret to brute-force low-entropy plaintexts much faster than configured.

The dump/1 callback that Cloak.Ecto.PBKDF2 (Cloak.Fields.PBKDF2 in cloak before the Ecto code moved to cloak_ecto) injects into a field module calls :pbkdf2.pbkdf2/4 with config[:size] in the iteration-count position. The :iterations setting is validated but never used. With the cloak_ecto defaults (iterations: 600_000, size: 32) each hash runs 32 PBKDF2 rounds instead of 600,000, so offline guessing of values such as email addresses costs about 18,750 times less than configured.

This issue affects cloak: from 0.7.0 before 1.0.0-alpha.0; cloak_ecto: from 1.0.0-alpha.0 onward.

Proof of concept

  1. Define a field module with use Cloak.Ecto.PBKDF2 and configure only a :secret, so that the defaults iterations: 600_000 and size: 32 apply.
  2. Call dump/1 on a value.
  3. Compare the result with :pbkdf2.pbkdf2({:hmac, :sha256}, value, secret, 32) and with the same call at 600,000 rounds. It matches the 32-round hash, not the 600,000-round hash, and returns in microseconds instead of about one second.

Weaknesses & attack patterns

Weakness

CWE-916 · Use of Password Hash With Insufficient Computational Effort in catalog → MITRE ↗

Attack patterns

CAPEC-55 · Rainbow Table Password Cracking MITRE ↗

An attacker who obtains a database dump and the PBKDF2 secret can recover hashed values with low entropy, such as email addresses, by offline guessing at a cost far below what the configuration promises.

Affected — Hex / cloak Hex.pm ↗ Repository ↗

≥ 0.7.0 < 1.0.0-alpha.0 affected
every other version: unaffected
cpe cpe:2.3:a:danielberkompas:cloak:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*
version type semver
modules · source files
modules 'Elixir.Cloak.Fields.PBKDF2'
source files lib/cloak/fields/pbkdf2.ex

Affected — GitHub / danielberkompas/cloak Repository ↗

≥ 8699e64 < 681c970 affected
every other version: unaffected
cpe cpe:2.3:a:danielberkompas:cloak:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*
version type git
modules · source files
modules 'Elixir.Cloak.Fields.PBKDF2'
source files lib/cloak/fields/pbkdf2.ex

Affected — Hex / cloak_ecto Hex.pm ↗ Repository ↗

≥ 1.0.0-alpha.0 and up affected
every other version: unaffected
cpe cpe:2.3:a:danielberkompas:cloak_ecto:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*
version type semver
modules · source files
modules 'Elixir.Cloak.Ecto.PBKDF2'
source files lib/cloak_ecto/types/pbkdf2.ex

Affected — GitHub / danielberkompas/cloak_ecto Repository ↗

≥ a8fa164 and up affected
every other version: unaffected
cpe cpe:2.3:a:danielberkompas:cloak_ecto:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*
version type git
modules · source files
modules 'Elixir.Cloak.Ecto.PBKDF2'
source files lib/cloak_ecto/types/pbkdf2.ex

Workarounds

Override dump/1 in the field module that uses Cloak.Ecto.PBKDF2, so that it calls :pbkdf2.pbkdf2/5 with the configured :iterations and :size. Then recompute all stored hashes, because the existing values no longer match.

References

Credits

Peter Ullrich Finder Reporter
Jonatan Männchen / EEF Coordinator

CVSS breakdown

CVSS:4.0/AV:N/AC:L/AT:P/PR:N/UI:N/VC:L/VI:N/VA:N/SC:N/SI:N/SA:N

Exploitability

Attack Vector
Network
Attack Complexity
Low
Attack Requirements
Present
Privileges Required
None
User Interaction
None

Vulnerable System

Confidentiality
Low
Integrity
None
Availability
None

Subsequent Systems

Confidentiality
None
Integrity
None
Availability
None
« All CVEs